PHR Letter to Ambassador Rice: Ask Iran about the Alaeis!
Posted on Tuesday, Feb 16, 2010 at 3:18 pm by Sarah Kalloch
PHR sent letters to more than 20 countries urging their UN reps to ask about the Alaeis during the Universal Periodic Review. This is PHR’s direct letter to Ambassador Rice:
February 11, 2010
Amb. Susan Rice
U.S. Mission to the UN
via fax: 212-415-4053Dear Ambassador Rice,
I am writing to you concerning the forthcoming seventh session of the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) Working Group of the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva. In this session, the human rights situation in the Islamic Republic of Iran will be reviewed under the UPR procedure on February 15.
I am hoping the US delegation in Geneva will be able to register early in the speaker’s list, to ask questions of the Iranian delegation regarding the massive crackdown on demonstrators protesting against unfair elections in June 2009, as well as the long list of cases of political prisoners, including many who were imprisoned even before the current unrest.
Physicians for Human Rights is gravely concerned about the case of Drs. Kamiar and Arash Alaei, two brothers in Iran who were known internationally for their work in the prevention and treatment of HIV/AIDS. In June 2008, on the eve of their departure to an international conference in Mexico on HIV/AIDS, the two physicians were arrested and charged with “communication with an enemy government” and “seeking to overthrow the government“ under Art. 508 of the Iran Islamic Penal Code. They were also tried on other, unspecified charges not made known to their lawyer or themselves and for which no evidence was produced.
Their only offense in fact had been traveling around the world and liaising with health workers to find solutions to the HIV/AIDS pandemic. At a closed, one-day trial in December 2008 where they were denied due process and adequate defense, the brothers were sentenced to three and six years, respectively, and incarcerated in prison in Tehran. We fear for their health and their lives in the abusive Iranian prison system.
We also fear for the state of public health innovation in Iran. Iran can not equate public health diplomacy and the quest for shared solutions to the world’s collective disease burden to treason. It is a serious fallacy and a danger to the people of Iran to keep science stifled and dedicated medical professions in prison for doing their job.
Drs. Kamiar and Arash Alaei had close ties to the US because they had studied in the US for a time. Dr. Kamiar Alaei was — at the time of his arrest — a doctoral candidate at SUNY Albany School of Public Health. He received his masters in public health from the Harvard School of Public Health in 2007, and was named a 2008 Asia 21 Fellow by the Asia Society in New York. Arash Alaei later joined his brother in New York for a study tour, during which time they worked with harm reduction and prison HIV groups across the state to share knowledge on HIV prevention innovations.
Since their arrest, the Alaeis’ colleagues and classmates have campaigned vigorously on their behalf, gaining the support of the American Medical Association. Together with other doctors in dozens of countries around the world they have been organizing Global Days of Action and contacting Iranian embassies to press for the release of the Alaei brothers. The New York Academy of Sciences also gave the Alaei brothers the 2009 Heinz R. Pagels Human Rights of Scientists Award.
In recent weeks, there has been some indication that the Iranian government may be prepared to release some political prisoners. During this time when Tehran may be willing to make concessions, we urge you to use your good offices to ensure that the case of the Alaei brothers is included on the list of cases and ensure that their plight is remembered.
We hope that your delegation can find ways to mention the plight of the Alaei brothers in public questions and statements and in bilateral negotiations at the UN Human Rights Council. The case of these two doctors has been submitted to the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights Defenders, as they defended the right of HIV/AIDS patients to obtain access to health care and remain free of discrimination and persecution.
If you would like further information on Drs. Kamiar and Aresh Alaei, visit http://iranfreethedocs.org
Sincerely,
A. Frank Donahue, CEO
Physicians for Human Rights



